Skip to main content

A Gold and Silver Merchant Cowers Behind 'Conspiracy Theory'

Dear Friend of GATA and Gold:

Britannia Bullion co-founder Matthew Jones' essay published today at his company's internet site and at Kitco, "Gold Is Cheap. The World's Biggest Buyers Know Something We Don't," dutifully cites the monetary virtues of gold and emphasizes the recent anomaly in gold prices:

https://www.britanniabullion.com/blog/gold-is-cheap.-the-worlds-biggest-buyers-know-something-we-dont

That is, Jones asks: How can gold's price be falling when central banks are hastening their substantial accumulation of it?

But Jones doesn't answer the question. 

He asserts, as many analysts have done, that governments and central banks may have big plans for the monetary metal, like diversification away from the U.S.-dollar-based financial system and protection against soaring debt and inflation. GATA dispatches have detailed those plans for months.

Jones doesn't say why gold has taken such a price beating lately, though his essay provides a hint he doesn't seem to grasp. 

Instead Jones tries to steer readers away from one particular explanation. He writes: "There is no need to imagine a coordinated international conspiracy to explain a correction."

Of course there is no need to imagine a conspiracy. For the conspiracy to suppress the price of gold in order to support the U.S. dollar and U.S. government bonds long has been documented and exposed. There is a need to persuade respectable people like Jones -- people with reputations they may be afraid to risk -- to acknowledge the truth.

So how could the gold price go down when major governments and central banks are frantically acquiring it?

The answer has been available since what was perhaps the original gold price suppression conspiracy, the London Gold Pool, collapsed in 1968. To suppress the price, Western governments and central banks first dishoarded some of their metal and then concocted futures markets and derivatives to divert demand from metal to paper that would never be delivered upon, creating a vast imaginary supply of gold.

Much documentation of that policy -- nearly all of it drawn from official archives -- is summarized here, where no conspiracies need to be imagined:

https://gata.org/node/20925

Most recently, thanks to the work of GATA's consultant on the Bank for International Settlements, Robert Lambourne, it has been shown that in the last few months the bank has facilitated the borrowing by certain governments or central banks of at least another 218 tonnes of gold for dispersal into the market for price suppression:

https://gata.org/node/25115

Contrary to what Jones may think, the BIS is not a fever dream. It is the very definition of conspiracy: an entity that secretly devises and implements plans and policies in pursuit of an objective that likely would fail if those plans and policies were developed and implemented openly.

It may not bother Jones that the BIS' monthly meetings, attended by representatives of its member governments and held at the bank's headquarters in Basel, Switzerland -- meetings at which the value of all capital, labor, goods, and services in the world is on the agenda -- are closed to the public. But it might bother more sincere adherents of gold's virtues as money and a defender of liberty.

Even governments and central banks seeking to acquire more gold may have an interest in suppressing its price, as Jones should have realized from his own essay.

"If you believe gold will play a much greater role in the global monetary system 10 years from now," he writes, "acquiring it more cheaply today represents an opportunity. Indeed, the last thing a substantial buyer necessarily wants is to pay progressively higher prices while still accumulating. They believe it is worth more. They just don't necessarily want to pay more."

So until their acquisitions are complete, governments and central banks might be glad to cooperate with price-suppression efforts temporarily and here and there. 

The U.S. economists Paul Brodsky and Lee Quaintance spelled all this out 14 years ago in a speculative study publicized by GATA:

https://gata.org/node/11373

Government and central bank intervention is not necessarily the only explanation for the many seemingly anomalous movements in the price of gold. But there would be fewer such movements without such intervention, and people promoting the monetary metals and purporting to analyze their markets would serve their audience much better if they didn't try to dismiss intervention as mere conspiracy theory. For intervention is both historical and contemporaneous fact, and facts are no respecters of reputations.

CHRIS POWELL, Secretary/Treasurer
Gold Anti-Trust Action Committee Inc.
CPowell@GATA.org

* * *

About the author

Newsletter Signup

GoldSeek Free Newsletters
GoldSeek Daily Edition
Gold & Silver Seeker Report
Gold Seek -- Peter Spina